Skip to main content

Empirical Evidence of Engel’s Law Among Social Grant Recievers

Engel's law is an observation in economics stating that as income increases, the proportion of income spent on food decreases, even if absolute expenditure on food increases. The law was named after the statistician Ernst Engel (1821–1896). One application of this statistic is treating it as a reflection of the living standard of a country. As this proportion — or "Engel coefficient" — increases, the country is by nature poorer; conversely a low Engel coefficient indicates a higher standard of living.
Engel's Law
image source: Wikipedia
Using data collected through National Social and Economic Survey (NSES) by BPS-Statistics Indonesia, I tried to examine the existence of Engel's Law among households that received social grants in West Papua-Indonesia. Some studies found that giving additional money to the low-income households resulted in an increase in overall expenditure on food (on absolute) but the proportion of income spent on food would decrease.

The table below showed that the average of household income per month was $240.17. The smallest household income per month was $37.63 and the highest one was $1000.25. If the household incomes were grouped, more than 30 percent of the households had income between $150 and $250 whereas less than 2 percent of households had income less than $50 per month. The amount of money, on absolute, spent on food consumption increased as the household income increased.

The highest average of food consumption per month was in household income group of above $550 which was $357.27. Household with income group below $50 had the lowest average of food consumption per month which was $33.02. Sampson et al. (2004) and Claire Smith et al. (2013) reported that giving additional money to the low-income households resulted in an increase in overall expenditure on food. This finding showed similar result with the previous studies, there was an indication of positive relationship between household income and the food consumption.

The Average of Food Consumption and Average of Percentage Income Spent on Food based on Household Income Per Month Group
Household Income Group ($)
Percentage of Household Income Group (%)
Average of Food Consumption ($)
Average of Percentage Income Spent on Food per month (%)
<50
1.50
33.02
73.13
50-150
26.45
62.98
61.55
150-250
34.77
130.70
67.01
250-350
20.08
176.74
60.41
350-450
7.73
232.95
59.46
450-550
5.03
267.02
53.75
>550
4.443
357.27
52.57

100.00
145.38
62.44
Source: Analysis Output of Microdata of National Social and Economic Survey-West Papua, 2015

On the other hand, the proportion of income spent on food decreased as the income increased. The highest average of percentage income spent on food per month was in the household with income group below $50 (73.13%). The lowest one was household with income group above $550 (52.57%). Even though averages of income spent on food per month for each groups of income were above 50 percent, there was decreasing trend as the household income increased. The graph below will clearly show the proof of Engel’s Law among households receiving social grants.

The Average of Percentage Income Spent on Food and Non-Food per Month Based on Household Income Group
Source: Analysis Output of Microdata of National Social and Economic Survey-West Papua, 2015

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How to Create Indonesia Map in R

Creating the Map In this article, I will try to explain how to make Indonesia Map in R. I will assume that you are already familiar with the basic codes in R. First, we need the required libraries : require (maps) #loading maps package require (mapdata) #loading mapdata package library(ggplot2) #ggplot2 package library(readxl) #package for read .xlsx file library(ggthemes) #package for ggplot2 theme library(ggrepel) #extendig the plotting package ggplot2 for maps Then, we prepare the data that contains the information of provinces name, latitude, and longitude of every province in Indonesia, e.g. : You can download the data in here:  Data Now open the file and create the polygon: setwd( "your file's path" ) #set your own directory mydata<- read _xlsx( "dummy.xlsx" ) #assign the data to "mydata" View(mydata) #view the data, notice the column of "latitude","longitude", "woe_label" glo...
1 comment
Read more

Modifying Some Plots in R

Grant Data : 500 Households that get Social Grant in a certain region, the data comes from Social and Economic Survey. Download the dummy data:  DATA grant <- read.csv( "grant.csv" ) #PFOODEXP: Proportion of Food Expenditure to Total Expenditure #HH_Income: Household Income ($) #HH_FOOD: Household Food Expenditure ($) #HH_Loc: Household Location (0: Rural, 1: Urban) #Educ_H: Household Head Education (Year) #HH_Size: Household Family Member #Gender_H: Household Head Gender (0: Female, 1: Male ) #Age_H: Household Head Age #Remove 1st column grant[ 1 ] <- NULL #change variable type to factor grant$Gender_H <- as.factor(grant$Gender_H) grant$HH_Loc <- as.factor(grant$HH_Loc) head(grant) ## PFOODEXP HH_Food HH_Loc Gender_H Age_H Educ_H HH_Size HH_Income ## 1 73.16933 675.1766 1 0 32 22 4 922.7590 ## 2 69.77417 596.2286 1 1 27 22 13 854.5119 ## 3 63.31992 585.4946 0 1 42 15...
Post a Comment
Read more

Interactive Visualisation Using R

Shiny is an R package that makes it easy to build interactive web apps straight from R. You can host standalone apps on a webpage or embed them in R Markdown documents or build dashboards . (R Studio) This one below is an example of how useful Shiny for data visualisation: *Sudden changes starting in year 2010 caused by the implementation of new HDI method Codes for the above visualisation: library(shiny) library(googleCharts) library(dplyr) library(readxl) head(data) ## # A tibble: 6 x 6 ## woe_label Island year Grdpc HDI Population ## <fct> <fct> <dbl> <dbl> <dbl> <dbl> ## 1 Aceh Sumatera 2000 4995. 65.3 3930905 ## 2 North Sumatra Sumatera 2000 5848. 66.6 11649655 ## 3 West Sumatra Sumatera 2000 5388. 65.8 4248931 ## 4 Riau Sumatera 2000 5746. 67.3 4957627 ## 5 Jambi Sumatera 2000 3503. 65.4 2413846 ## 6 South Sumatra Sumatera 2000 4506. ...
Post a Comment
Read more